County Manager Heidi Petito Delivers Outstanding Results Despite Political Challenges

Flagler County Administrator Heidi Petito continues to demonstrate steadfast leadership, guiding the county through numerous advancements despite facing political challenges from within the commission. Her recent evaluations reflect a commendable performance, overshadowed only by the sharp criticisms from Commissioner Leann Pennington, whose persistent opposition raises concerns about internal dynamics affecting county governance.

Consistent Leadership Amidst Challenges

In her latest performance evaluation, Petito achieved an 81% score, marking an improvement over the previous year’s 78%. This evaluation period covered the 12 months between mid-October 2023 and mid-October 2024, encompassing the final year of then-Commissioners Donald O’Brien’s and Dave Sullivan’s tenures, prior to the induction of their successors, Pam Richardson and Kim Carney. Notably, Sullivan submitted an evaluation identical to the previous year’s, awarding Petito perfect scores across all categories, totaling 50 points out of a possible 50. Commissioner Greg Hansen has yet to submit his evaluation but indicated it would mirror last year’s perfect scores. Commission Chair Andy Dance awarded Petito 39 points, while Commissioner Pennington assigned a mere 23 points, reflecting her ongoing critical stance.

Commissioner Pennington’s Persistent Opposition

Commissioner Pennington has been vocal in her criticism of Petito, particularly regarding the handling of the River-to-Sea Preserve situation in Marineland and the communication with the school superintendent concerning school resource deputies. Her evaluation highlighted these issues, contrasting sharply with the more favorable assessments from other commissioners.

Pennington’s critical perspective is not new; she has consistently expressed intentions to terminate Petito’s employment. An anonymous county employee close to the commission disclosed, “Since first taking office, Commissioner Pennington has told many people that she intends to fire Mrs. Petito,” reflecting ongoing internal tensions.

A Record of Achievements

Despite the political undercurrents, Petito’s tenure is marked by significant accomplishments:

  • Infrastructure Development: She has been instrumental in advancing stormwater mitigation efforts, enhancing road maintenance projects, and securing funding for critical infrastructure developments.

  • Fiscal Responsibility: Petito maintained a balanced budget without increasing taxes while expanding essential services for residents.

  • Emergency Preparedness: Under her guidance, the county strengthened its emergency response framework, ensuring better preparedness for hurricanes and other crises.

  • Community Engagement: She spearheaded initiatives to increase transparency and public participation, granting citizens greater access to decision-making processes.

Looking Ahead

As Flagler County moves forward, the focus remains on sustaining progress and addressing internal challenges. Petito’s leadership has been a cornerstone of the county’s development, and her ability to navigate political adversity will be crucial in maintaining the trajectory of growth and stability.

The upcoming evaluations and commission meetings will serve as a litmus test for the county’s commitment to prioritizing effective governance over political discord. Residents and stakeholders alike hope that the demonstrated successes under Petito’s administration will continue to flourish, ensuring that Flagler County remains resilient and prosperous in the face of internal and external challenges.